httpbis: Ticket #19: Bodies on GET (and other) requests

Link: http://trac.tools.ietf.org/wg/httpbis/trac/ticket/19

Origin: http://www.w3.org/mid/200606221739.k5MHd3PA013395@pobox-pa.hpl.hp.com

Component: p2-semantics

Is a request body allowed on GET? Other requests?

Mails

Mails by Sender (Top 10) Mails by Month

Entities Kim Horne (kim@pookzilla.com) (2002-08-14)
- Re: Entities Alex Rousskov (rousskov@measurement-factory.com) (2002-08-14)
- RE: Entities Larry Masinter (LMM@acm.org) (2002-08-15)
  - Re: Entities Kim Horne (kim@pookzilla.com) (2002-08-16)
    - Re: Entities Alex Rousskov (rousskov@measurement-factory.com) (2002-08-18)
      - RE: Entities Larry Masinter (LMM@acm.org) (2002-08-19)
        
        Re: Entities Jeffrey Mogul (Jeff.Mogul@hp.com) (2002-08-19)
        
        Re: Entities Roy T. Fielding (fielding@apache.org) (2002-08-19)
        
        RE: Entities Larry Masinter (LMM@acm.org) (2002-08-20)
        
        Re: Entities Roy T. Fielding (fielding@apache.org) (2002-08-20)
        
        Re: Entities Jeffrey Mogul (Jeff.Mogul@hp.com) (2002-08-20)
        
        Re: Entities Roy T. Fielding (fielding@apache.org) (2002-08-20)
HTTP rfc related question, Content-length: 0 in GET request Kuba Witczak (czesacz@gmail.com) (2006-06-21)
- Re: HTTP rfc related question, Content-length: 0 in GET request Sylvain Hellegouarch (sh@defuze.org) (2006-06-21)
- Re: HTTP rfc related question, Content-length: 0 in GET request Julian Reschke (julian.reschke@gmx.de) (2006-06-22)
  - Re: HTTP rfc related question, Content-length: 0 in GET request Jeffrey Mogul (Jeff.Mogul@hp.com) (2006-06-22)
- Re: HTTP rfc related question, Content-length: 0 in GET request Mark Baker (distobj@acm.org) (2006-06-22)
i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-01-15)
- Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests William A. Rowe, Jr. (wrowe@rowe-clan.net) (2007-01-15)
- Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Mark Baker (distobj@acm.org) (2007-01-15)
- Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Scott Lawrence (scott@skrb.org) (2007-01-15)
  - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Roy T. Fielding (fielding@gbiv.com) (2007-01-15)
    - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-01-15)
      - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-16)
      - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests William A. Rowe, Jr. (wrowe@rowe-clan.net) (2007-01-16)
      - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Scott Lawrence (scott@skrb.org) (2007-01-16)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-16)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-01-16)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Roy T. Fielding (fielding@gbiv.com) (2007-01-16)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Roy T. Fielding (fielding@gbiv.com) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests William A. Rowe, Jr. (wrowe@rowe-clan.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-16)
        
        Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests William A. Rowe, Jr. (wrowe@rowe-clan.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Message delimiting security issues Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Travis Snoozy (ai2097@users.sourceforge.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Julian Reschke (julian.reschke@gmx.de) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues William A. Rowe, Jr. (wrowe@rowe-clan.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Travis Snoozy (ai2097@users.sourceforge.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Travis Snoozy (ai2097@users.sourceforge.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Julian Reschke (julian.reschke@gmx.de) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues William A. Rowe, Jr. (wrowe@rowe-clan.net) (2007-01-17)
        
        Re: Message delimiting security issues Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-01-18)
- Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Henrik Nordstrom (hno@squid-cache.org) (2007-01-16)
  - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Henrik Nordstrom (hno@squid-cache.org) (2007-01-16)
  - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Jamie Lokier (jamie@shareable.org) (2007-01-16)
    - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Henrik Nordstrom (hno@squid-cache.org) (2007-01-16)
    - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Yves Lafon (ylafon@w3.org) (2007-01-17)
      - Re: i19 Bodies on GET (and other) requests Jamie Lokier (jamie@shareable.org) (2007-01-18)
i19 - bodies on GET -- round 2 Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-05-15)
- Re: i19 - bodies on GET -- round 2 Julian Reschke (julian.reschke@gmx.de) (2007-05-15)
  - Re: i19 - bodies on GET -- round 2 Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-05-16)
    - Re: i19 - bodies on GET -- round 2 Julian Reschke (julian.reschke@gmx.de) (2007-05-16)
Request methods that allow an entity-body Scott Nichol (snicholnews@scottnichol.com) (2007-11-29)
- Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Mark Baker (distobj@acm.org) (2007-11-30)
  - Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body David Morris (dwm@xpasc.com) (2007-11-30)
    - Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Adrien de Croy (adrien@qbik.com) (2007-11-30)
      - Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Scott Nichol (snicholnews@scottnichol.com) (2007-11-30)
        
        Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-11-30)
        
        Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Mark Baker (distobj@acm.org) (2007-11-30)
        
        Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body [i19] Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2007-11-30)
        
        Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body [i19] Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-12-02)
        
        Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body [i19] Mark Baker (distobj@acm.org) (2007-12-02)
      - Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-11-30)
      - Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Robert Siemer (Robert.Siemer-httpwg@backsla.sh) (2007-12-08)
        
        Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body Henrik Nordstrom (henrik@henriknordstrom.net) (2007-12-10)
Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body [i19] Mark Nottingham (mnot@mnot.net) (2008-01-22)
- Re: Request methods that allow an entity-body [i19] David Morris (dwm@xpasc.com) (2008-01-23)

Associated Checkins

julian.reschke@gmx.de (Tue, 22 Jan 2008 12:23:59 GMT): [171]: Resolve #19: as proposed in ...

History

: comment added; version set (Sat, 22 Dec 2007 04:13:59 GMT)

version set to d00

: comment added; component, milestone set (Sat, 22 Dec 2007 04:19:18 GMT)

component set to semantics
milestone set to 01

: milestone deleted; comment added (Sat, 22 Dec 2007 04:22:14 GMT)

milestone deleted

: comment added; milestone set (Fri, 04 Jan 2008 05:59:04 GMT)

milestone set to unassigned

: comment added; milestone changed (Tue, 22 Jan 2008 12:03:36 GMT)

milestone changed from unassigned to 02.

Consensus to, in RFC2616 section 4.3:

Change "does not allow" to "explicitly disallows", as per http://www.w3.org/mid/64972E13-483B-4F69-94FD-F2EE516286A8@mnot.net
Replace the last sentence with:

When a request message contains both a message-body of non-zero length and a method that does not define any semantics for that request message-body, then an origin server SHOULD either ignore the message-body or respond with an appropriate error message (e.g., 413). A proxy or gateway, when presented the same request, SHOULD either forward the request inbound with the message-body or ignore the message-body when determining a response.

as per http://www.w3.org/mid/9C43F5AB-C3D7-4584-8F12-A9F459D3817F@gbiv.com

: comment added; resolution set; status changed (Tue, 22 Jan 2008 12:23:59 GMT)

status changed from new to closed.
resolution set to fixed

Fixed in [171].

Related Information

Issues List Index